Peak Oil Anarchy

Peak Oil is indisputable, inevitable and -- probably -- imminent. As the Cheap Oil era ends & oil supplies grow ever more scarce, our consumerist, earth-eating economy will go into convulsions & industrial civilization will teeter on the brink of collapse. Best be prepared! Peak Oil could herald a Golden Age of Anarchy. In Leviathan's ashes, we could create new decentralized communities of mutual aid, solidarity against oppression, & egalitarian harmony. May this be a map to the terrain ahead!

Thursday, December 22, 2005

A risk of total collapse

by Dylan Evans, Wednesday December 21, 2005, The Guardian

Is it possible that global civilisation might collapse
within our lifetime or that of our children? Until recently, such an idea was the preserve of lunatics and cults. In the past few years, however, an increasing number of intelligent and credible people have been warning that global collapse is a genuine possibility. And many of these are sober scientists, including Lord May, David King and Jared Diamond - people not usually given to exaggeration or drama.

The new doomsayers all point to the same collection of threats --- climate change, resource depletion and population imbalances being the most important. What makes them especially afraid is that many of these dangers are interrelated, with one tending to exacerbate the others. It is necessary to tackle them all at once if we are to have any chance of avoiding global collapse, they warn.

Many societies - from the Maya in Mexico to the Polynesians of Easter Island - have collapsed in the past, often because of the very same dangers that threaten us. As Diamond explains in his recent book, Collapse, the Maya depleted one of their principal resources - trees - and this triggered a series of problems such as soil erosion, decrease of useable farmland and drought. The growing population that drove this overexploitation was thus faced with a diminishing amount of food, which led to increasing migration and bloody civil war. The collapse of the civilisation on Easter Island followed a similar pattern, with deforestation leading to other ecological problems and warfare.

Unlike these dead societies, our civilisation is global. On the positive side, globalisation means that when one part of the world gets into trouble, it can appeal to the rest of the world for help. Neither the Maya nor the inhabitants of Easter Island had this luxury, because they were in effect isolated civilisations. On the negative side, globalisation means that when one part of the world gets into trouble, the trouble can quickly be exported. If modern civilisation collapses, it will do so everywhere. Everyone now stands or falls together.

Global collapse would probably still follow the same basic pattern as a local collapse but on a greater scale. With the Maya, the trouble began in one region but engulfed the whole civilisation. Today, as climate change makes some areas less hospitable than others, increasing numbers of people will move to the more habitable areas. The increasing population will make them less habitable and lead to further migration in a domino effect. Huge movements of people and capital will put the international financial system under strain and may cause it to give way. In his book The Future of Money, the Belgian economist Bernard Lietaer argues that the global monetary system is already very unstable. Financial crises have certainly grown in scale and frequency over the past decade. The South-east Asian crisis of 1997 dwarfed the Mexican crisis of 1994 and was followed by the Russian crash of 1998 and the Brazilian crisis of 1999. This is another example of the way globalisation can exacerbate rather than minimise the risk of total collapse.

This would not be the end of the world. The collapse of modern civilisation would entail the deaths of billions of people but not the end of the human race. A few Mayans survived by abandoning their cities and retreating into the jungle, where they continue to live to this day. In the same way, some would survive the end of the industrial age by reverting to a preindustrial lifestyle.

The enormity of such a scenario makes it hard to imagine. It is human nature to assume that the world will carry on much as it has been. But it is worth remembering that in the years preceding the collapse of their civilisation, the Mayans too were convinced that their world would last forever.

ยท Dylan Evans is a senior lecturer at the University of the West of England

[POA comment: What interests us is not whether global civilization will collapse -- that seems inevitable -- but whether public discussion of the possibility makes it more of less imminent. Does the thought of collapse lead civilized people to have a crisis of confidence, a loss of faith, about its continuity, and spur them to cease investing in the complexity that sustains it? And to re-invest in simple forms of personal survival? Or does it frighten them into intensifying their investment in civilization and its self-perpetuating "stable" institutions: banks, stocks, bonds, college educations, suburban homes, gratuitous consumption? Which option accelerates colllapse, and which postpones it? Either way, it is fascinating to see one of the world's top newspapers editorialize about the likelihood of the collapse of modern civilization. One last question: Will the collapse be televised?]


  • At 7:08 PM, Blogger upssidetown said…

    Here are some links that I believe will be interested

  • At 7:44 AM, Blogger Seeker of Answers said…

    I am always surprised that the obvious is so difficult to understand. I keep feeling reminded of a book by Daniel Goleman titled "VITAL LIES SIMPLE TRUTHS: The Psychology of Self Deception".

    The big problem is that there seems to be absolutely no way out. It will come to a crash of such unbelievable proportions that no conceivable action could possibly be more than feeble cosmetics. It is like being dropped out of an airplane without a parachute. No amount of contemplation will stop the impact. I guess you know the famous Philipp K. Dick quote: "Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away."

    Some might also say: why not party as long as it lasts? And who knows - maybe some miracle happens and someone will pick up the poor falling guy in mid air and beam him directly to paradise? And perhaps in the bigger scheme of things it is pretty meaningless if mankind - or this thing we call western civilization - perish?


Post a Comment

<< Home